The impartial supply for well being coverage analysis, polling, and information.
The impartial supply for well being coverage analysis, polling, and information.
Ivette Gomez, Alina Salganicoff, and Laurie Sobel
Printed:
Abortions occurring at or after 21 weeks gestational age are uncommon. They’re typically tough to acquire, as they’re solely accessible in a handful of states, carried out by a small subset of abortion suppliers and are usually expensive and time-intensive. But, these abortions obtain a disproportionate share of consideration within the information, coverage and the legislation. Discussions on this subject are sometimes fraught with misinformation; for instance, intense public discussions have been sparked after a number of presidential candidates claimed there have been abortions occurring “moments before birth” and even “after birth.” In actuality, these situations don’t happen, nor are they authorized, in america. Dialogue of this subject is distorted and infected by the terminology that’s generally used to explain abortions later in being pregnant— together with “late-term,” “post-viability,” “partial start,” “dismemberment” and “born-alive” abortions. There have been some information studies of former President and present Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump’s help of a national 16-week abortion ban that may get rid of entry to abortions later in being pregnant besides when the lifetime of the pregnant particular person is in peril or the being pregnant is a results of rape/incest. This temporary explains why people could search abortions later in being pregnant, how typically these procedures happen, and the assorted legal guidelines which regulate entry to abortions later in being pregnant throughout the nation.
Clarifying Being pregnant Relationship: pregnancies are measured utilizing gestational age (GA), calculated in days and weeks because the first day of the final menstrual interval (LMP). Since some folks have no idea the date of their LMP, ultrasound can be used to calculate GA. Submit-fertilization or fertilization age refers back to the time because the egg and sperm fused to create a fertilized egg. Fertilization happens roughly 2 weeks after menses, thus gestational age by LMP predates fertilization age by ~2 weeks. By conference, gestational age is used to debate being pregnant courting as most pregnant people know their LMP, nonetheless sure abortion rules reference fertilization age as a substitute.
“Late time period” abortion usually refers to abortions obtained at or after 21 weeks, nonetheless it’s not an accepted medical time period, neither is there a consensus round to which gestational ages it refers. Members of the medical community have criticized the time period “late-term” abortion, because it implies abortions are happening after a being pregnant has reached “time period” (37 weeks) or “late time period” (>41 weeks) which is fake. The truth is, the American School of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) has written that “late-term abortion” has no medical that means. As such, this temporary discusses abortions occurring at ≥21 weeks gestation as abortions later in being pregnant, but it surely needs to be famous that 21 weeks is a largely arbitrary cutoff based mostly on how the CDC collects knowledge on abortions. Abortions at this stage in being pregnant are generally known as “later abortions” by the medical neighborhood as nicely.
On June 24, 2022, in Dobbs v. Jackson Girls’s Well being, the Supreme Court docket overturned Roe and eradicated the federal constitutional normal that had protected the suitable to abortion. With none federal requirements, states can now set their very own insurance policies banning or defending abortion at any level in being pregnant. This has drastically modified the panorama of abortion in america, as 14 states have now banned abortion at any stage of being pregnant and 11 others have gestational limits banning abortion after a sure level in being pregnant, akin to earlier than cardiac exercise is detected within the fetus or as much as a sure variety of weeks of being pregnant.
Nevertheless, in states with out abortion bans or gestational bans earlier than 22 weeks LMP, entry to abortions later in being pregnant is usually restricted for a lot of causes, together with viability bans, bans on sure abortion procedures, and a restricted variety of abortion suppliers who’re educated or prepared to supply abortions later in being pregnant. Whereas viability, the purpose when a fetus can survive outdoors the womb, is not the federal normal that defines the legality of abortion within the U.S., 18 states that also permit abortions presently have legal guidelines proscribing abortion at “viability” or at 24 weeks LMP / 3rd trimester, when viability is presumed to happen (Determine 1). These states have abortion exemptions just like the exemptions in abortion bans (akin to to protect the well being or lifetime of the pregnant particular person) and gestational limits, defining when an abortion is allowed to be carried out after viability. A lot of the 13 states that limit abortions at “viability” outline it as the purpose the place a doctor or different healthcare supplier determines whether or not a fetus can survive outdoors the womb. 5 of those states embody language of their abortion insurance policies defining viability as the purpose the place there’s a probability that the fetus might survive with out the “utility of extraordinary measures” and one other three states have language clarifying the fetus might survive with or with out extraordinary measures.
Some states have additionally handed legal guidelines banning clinicians from performing sure abortion procedures which might be generally utilized in later abortions (Determine 2). Virtually all abortions carried out at or after 21 weeks are carried out by a dilation and evacuation (D&E) process (93–95% per CDC knowledge). This entails dilating the cervix and evacuating the being pregnant tissue utilizing forceps, with or with out suction. D&Es may be carried out safely as much as at the very least 28 weeks gestational age, and when in comparison with their various of labor induction, have been discovered to be faster and lead to fewer complications; additional, many people could favor surgical administration as they are going to be sedated and should not have to endure labor and supply of the fetus.
Nebraska has enacted a D&E ban, though the state additionally has a 12-week gestational ban. 9 states ban dilation and extractions (D&Xs), a hardly ever used abortion process additionally known as an intact D&E or a “partial start abortion” by policymakers (Appendix Table 1).
Along with gestational age limits and methodology bans used for abortions later in being pregnant, abortions later in being pregnant are topic to the identical rules that apply to abortions earlier in being pregnant, together with necessary waiting periods and physician and hospital requirements.
Abortions occurring at or after 21 weeks gestation are uncommon. Based on the CDC’s Abortion Surveillance Information for 2021, previous to the Dobbs choice, the huge variety of abortions (96%) occurred at or earlier than 15 weeks gestation, whereas 3% occurred from 16 to twenty weeks gestation, and simply 1% of abortions have been carried out at or after 21 weeks (Determine 3). This quantities to roughly 4,100 abortions per yr occurring at or after 21 weeks. Nevertheless, this estimate solely consists of the 41 reporting areas that report abortions to the CDC by gestational age and excludes main states akin to California and New York. The share of abortions occurring at or earlier than 13 weeks gestation has remained stable over the last few decades at 91-92%, nonetheless inside this timeframe, extra abortions are occurring earlier in being pregnant, at or earlier than 9 weeks. That is probably partially as a result of larger availability of medication abortions over the past twenty years.
The CDC doesn’t elaborate on the breakdown by gestational age for abortions occurring previous 21 weeks, however it’s probably that the overwhelming majority happen quickly after 21 weeks moderately than a lot later within the being pregnant. Whereas very restricted modern knowledge exists on this situation, a study from 1992 estimated 0.02% of all abortions occurred after 26 weeks gestation (320 to 600 instances per yr).
Preliminary findings from a examine on abortion provision because the Dobbs choice has discovered that sufferers dwelling in states the place abortion is banned or restricted have skilled elevated delays in acquiring abortion care, partially as a result of arranging out-of-state journey to states the place abortion is authorized and restricted appointment availability in abortion clinics in states the place abortion is authorized. Out-of-state journey for abortion providers doubled within the first half of 2023 in comparison with the primary half of 2020, probably pushed by the overturning of Roe. Delays in accessing abortion providers push individuals who need an abortion additional alongside of their pregnancies, which might result in a rise within the share of people that want abortions later in being pregnant.
As well as, even when sufferers can journey to a unique state to entry later abortion providers, there are a couple of clinicians who present abortions later in being pregnant. This was the case even earlier than the Dobbs choice. Researchers from Advancing New Requirements in Reproductive Well being (ANSIRH) discovered that in 2023, 60 clinics provided abortions at or after 24 weeks and 5 clinics offered providers at or after 28 weeks, that means that almost all people in want of abortions later in being pregnant typically need to journey important distances to search out an accessible and educated supplier.1 A College of California San Francisco study discovered that in comparison with earlier than Dobbs there was a slight increase within the variety of abortion clinics that present abortions after 24 weeks after the Dobbs ruling. Abortions at this stage additionally usually require two days to finish with inpatient care, versus outpatient or at-home administration that’s attainable earlier in being pregnant. Some amenities within the U.S. carry out abortions later in being pregnant as outpatient procedures (as much as sure gestational ages), however it’s much less widespread than providing inpatient take care of these instances.
People search abortions later in being pregnant for a number of reasons. As a part of the Turnaway study out of the College of California San Francisco, from 2008-2010 over 440 women have been requested about why they skilled delays in acquiring abortion care, if any (Determine 4). Virtually half of people who obtained an abortion after 20 weeks didn’t suspect they have been pregnant till later in being pregnant, and different limitations to care included lack of understanding about the place to entry an abortion, transportation difficulties, lack of insurance coverage protection and incapacity to pay for the process. A 2022 study of sufferers searching for abortions later in being pregnant discovered that they fell into two classes: both that they had discovered new details about their pregnancies that made them not fascinating, akin to not discovering out they have been pregnant till very late within the being pregnant or the emergence of great fetal or their very own well being situation; or experiencing limitations to abortion providers earlier within the being pregnant that power them to delay the abortion till the third trimester.
Delays Stemming from Monetary Limitations to Abortion Entry: Abortions may be cost-prohibitive for a lot of; a examine inspecting abortion prices in 2021 discovered that the median out-of-pocket self-pay prices for remedy abortion providers was $568, $625 for first trimester procedural abortions, and $775 for second trimester procedural abortions (vary $465 to $2,885). These prices don’t account for lodging and transportation prices, lack of work or childcare prices, which might drive the value higher. Third trimester abortion costs can range from a pair thousand {dollars} to over $25,000, relying on how far alongside the being pregnant is and the way clinically complicated it’s. The Federal Reserve Board discovered 32% of U.S. adults should not have sufficient in financial savings to pay for a $400 emergency expense, that means many people could have to delay having an abortion till they’ll increase the mandatory funds.
Fetal Anomalies: People additionally search abortions later in being pregnant as a result of medical causes. With medical advances, many genetic fetal anomalies may be detected early in being pregnant; for instance, chorionic villus sampling can diagnose Down Syndrome or cystic fibrosis as earlier as 10 weeks gestation. Structural fetal anomalies, nonetheless, are sometimes detected a lot later in being pregnant. As a part of routine care, a fetal anatomy scan is carried out round 20 weeks, which entails ultrasound imaging of all of the creating organs. Many structural anomalies are found right now that may not have been obvious beforehand. A proportion of those are lethal fetal anomalies, that means that the fetus will nearly actually die earlier than or shortly after start, that means the fetus could also be nonviable (consensus doesn’t at all times exist as to which anomalies are deadly, and thus nonviable). In these instances, many people want to terminate their pregnancies, moderately than threat carrying the being pregnant till the fetus or new child passes away. Fairly often these pregnancies are desired, making this choice exceedingly tough for folks. Insufficient data exist to know what number of abortions later in being pregnant happen as a result of fetal anomalies, however a study by Washington College Hospital confirmed nearly all ladies whose fetuses had deadly fetal anomalies selected to terminate their pregnancies. Three (Alabama, Indiana and West Virginia) of the fourteen states with abortion bans and 5 states with early gestational bans (Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Utah) presently have exceptions for pregnancies with deadly fetal anomalies, however it’s unknown whether or not any abortions underneath these exemptions have occurred. Among the many states with viability or close to viability bans, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts and New Hampshire have exemptions for fetal anomalies. Pregnant individuals who reside in states the place abortion is banned and with no fetal anomaly exceptions who’re unable to journey out of state may be compelled to hold their pregnancies to time period and ship infants who’re stillborn or die shortly after start.
A 2011 survey of maternal fetal medicine (MFM) medical doctors—specialists who handle pregnancies with fetal anomalies— discovered most agreed that termination of being pregnant as a result of a deadly fetal anomaly needs to be allowed in all circumstances (76%). The bulk (75%) focus on abortion as a administration possibility quickly after diagnosing a deadly fetal anomaly, however providers for terminating pregnancies in these situations are restricted. Even over decade earlier than the Dobbs choice, solely 40% of MFM medical doctors labored at healthcare facilities providing abortions previous 24 weeks for deadly fetal anomalies. An extra 12% knew of obtainable providers <50 miles away.
Well being Threat to the Pregnant Particular person: Life threatening circumstances can also develop later in being pregnant. These embody circumstances like early extreme preeclampsia, newly recognized cancer requiring immediate therapy, and intrauterine an infection (chorioamnionitis) typically at the side of untimely rupture of the amniotic sac (PPROM). If these circumstances happen in a state the place abortion is authorized, the pregnant particular person could pursue termination of being pregnant to protect their very own well being. All states that ban abortion, have gestational bans, or restrict abortion at or close to viability, have exceptions permitting for abortions to happen when the life of the pregnant particular person is in peril, and 37 states have exceptions for when the well being of the pregnant particular person is in danger (Determine 5). Former President Donald Trump reportedly helps a 16-week nationwide abortion ban with exceptions for when the lifetime of the pregnant particular person is in peril and in instances for rape or incest, however the 16-week nationwide ban wouldn’t have an exception for when the well being of the pregnant particular person is in danger. It’s probably {that a} ban akin to this may be structured in order that it could restrict abortions in states that presently allow abortions later in being pregnant, however permit states with abortion bans or gestational restrictions to maintain their legal guidelines in impact.
The legal standards states use to find out when a pregnant particular person qualifies for a life or well being exception may be ambiguous, with some requirements leaving physicians in a legally weak place that permit a prosecutor to convey an professional witness to contradict the doctor’s medical judgment. In a latest case out of Texas, Kate Cox, a pregnant ladies searching for an abortion, sought a courtroom order that may have allowed her to have an abortion underneath the exceptions to the Texas abortion ban. Fearing prosecution for offering abortion care that she believed it match underneath the abortion ban’s exception based mostly upon her good religion medical judgement, Ms. Cox’s doctor requested a Texas District Court docket to find out that offering the abortion was not a violation of the state’s ban. Whereas the District Court docket agreed with the plaintiffs that the case certified for an exception, the Texas state Lawyer Normal wrote a letter to the hospital stating that his workplace would nonetheless implement the state abortion ban if abortion care was offered. Consequently, the Texas Supreme Court docket overruled the decrease district courtroom, discovering that the doctor’s “good religion perception” was inadequate to qualify for the exception, and solely abortions which might be licensed to be mandatory underneath the “cheap medical judgement” normal are allowable underneath Texas legislation.
In states the place abortion is banned, there have been questions and confusion about how unwell a pregnant particular person should be for an abortion underneath a well being exception to be carried out. There are reports of sufferers having well being problems that aren’t life threatening in the intervening time they’re searching for care, and being despatched residence and subsequently creating severe problems that do threaten their lives because of this. In Idaho, Indiana, Tennessee, and Texas, physicians and individuals who have been denied abortion care regardless of going through being pregnant problems that jeopardized their well being have filed lawsuits concerning harms skilled because of the shortage of well being exceptions of their respective state abortion bans. They’re asking for courts to make clear the scope of the state bans’ well being exceptions and for doctor judgment in making determinations about abortion as a medical therapy for emergent circumstances to be granted larger deference.
In July 2022, the Division of Well being and Human Providers (HHS) issued guidance concerning the enforcement of EMTALA (Emergency Medical Therapy and Lively Labor Act), the legislation that requires hospitals that take Medicare enrolled sufferers to carry out acceptable medical screening examination to any affected person who presents on the emergency division and to supply stabilizing care to sufferers recognized as having an emergency medical situation. The 2022 steerage clarifies that hospitals and physicians have obligations to supply stabilizing care, together with abortion in medically acceptable circumstances, when a affected person presenting at an emergency division is experiencing an emergency medical situation. Because the steerage was issued, HHS has sued the state of Idaho for his or her abortion ban, which didn’t comprise exceptions for well being, and the state of Texas has sued to dam enforcement of the steerage in Texas. The 2 federal district courts which have thought of this situation have reached reverse choices. In Texas, a federal district courtroom blocked HHS from implementing the EMTALA steerage in Texas and the Biden administration has appealed this choice to the 5th Circuit Court docket of Appeals. In Idaho, a federal district courtroom issued a short lived keep blocking a part of the Idaho ban, which was additionally stayed by the 9th Circuit Court docket of Appeals. Nevertheless, in January 2024, the Supreme Court docket of america agreed to listen to the Biden Administration’s problem to the Idaho abortion ban and allowed Idaho’s ban to be absolutely in impact whereas the litigation is ongoing.
Recognizing that entry to abortions later in being pregnant generally is a well being preserving or life-saving medical service to a small group of pregnant folks, but very tough to entry, a couple of states have sought to develop entry to abortions later in being pregnant. The New York Reproductive Health Act enacted in January 2019 expanded protections for abortion suppliers and pregnant people who’ve abortions after 24 weeks in instances of well being or life endangerment or deadly fetal anomalies. In Might 2023, Minnesota repealed its viability ban and in July 2023, Maine enacted L.D. 1619, permitting abortions after viability anytime a physician deemed them medically mandatory. Beforehand the legislation solely allowed abortions after viability if the pregnant particular person’s life was in peril.
The authors would love acknowledge Gabriela Weigel, MD, former KFF-UCSF Fellow, who co-authored the 2019 model of this temporary.
The authors wish to acknowledge Jennifer Karlin, MD, PhD (College of California, San Francisco) for her overview of an earlier model of this temporary.
Berglas NB, Schroeder R, Kaller S, Stewart C, and Upadhyay UD. Change in service availability of 2nd and third trimester abortion care following Dobbs. Society of Household Planning Convention, October 2023.
← Return to text
KFF Headquarters: 185 Berry St., Suite 2000, San Francisco, CA 94107 | Cellphone 650-854-9400
Washington Workplaces and Barbara Jordan Convention Middle: 1330 G Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20005 | Cellphone 202-347-5270
www.kff.org | E-mail Alerts: kff.org/e mail | fb.com/KFF | twitter.com/kff
The impartial supply for well being coverage analysis, polling, and information, KFF is a nonprofit group based mostly in San Francisco, California.
