Motivation and obstacles for weight management among young women – a qualitative study with a public health focus … – BMC Public Health
Commercial
BMC Public Health quantity 17, Article quantity: 417 (2017)
8999
14
11
Metrics details
As a result of a worldwide improve in chubby and weight problems, weight-management by life-style adjustments has change into an necessary public well being challenge. Adolescents and younger adults comprise a susceptible group. The transition into maturity represents a stage in life when establishing good life-style habits for the long run is necessary. The purpose of this research was to discover motivation and obstacles for weight discount, weight upkeep and wholesome life-style decisions in younger girls.
We carried out semi-structured in depth interviews with 12 younger girls, each chubby and regular weight, recruited from a school-based inhabitants survey. By way of thematic evaluation we searched the interview textual content for related which means models that emerged as subjects that illuminated our analysis questions.
A robust motivation for acquiring or protecting regular weight was clearly current among the many individuals. Impartial of weight-group, the individuals described elevated ranges of bodily exercise, higher consuming habits and regularity in day by day life as fascinating adjustments. Mother and father had been described as necessary influencers concerning life-style habits. A number of individuals expressed a necessity for extra details about wholesome diet and consuming. Their motivation for bodily exercise trusted a constructive social setting and parts of pleasure. The individuals described the transition into maturity together with shifting out of their mother and father’ dwelling and different structural adjustments in on a regular basis life, as difficult. It affected their meals decisions and consuming habits and different life-style points. Excessive prices of wholesome meals and sports activities actions had been regularly talked about among the many obstacles they encountered.
The outcomes revealed an apparent motivation for life-style adjustments in people and environmental challenges for younger girls within the related stage of their life-course. There appears to be a necessity for well being methods that strengthens people’ capability to beat the environmental challenges within the transition to maturity. This could embrace dependable and accessible well being training/info concerning wholesome diet, consuming habits, meals decisions and preparation of meals. Structural initiatives equivalent to simpler entry to inexpensive wholesome meals and cheaper alternatives for bodily exercise and sports activities ought to be thought of.
Peer Review reports
After many years dominated by infectious illnesses, the worldwide improve in chubby and weight problems [1], along with the shift in the direction of a neo-liberal public well being ideology [2], have made weight discount and weight upkeep by life-style adjustments an necessary matter in public well being insurance policies. The principle goal is to stop non-communicable illnesses by selling wholesome existence. Most efforts to reverse the event in the direction of elevated physique weight have been unsuccessful thus far, on each a inhabitants degree and a person degree [3, 4]. Nonetheless, particular person accountability is within the forefront when public well being insurance policies are mentioned, whereas the accountability of related societal establishments, such because the meals business and the favored press, is downplayed [5]. The controversy on benefits or disadvantages of methods on a high-risk, particular person degree or a inhabitants degree in public well being points has been happening for a number of many years [6]. In recent times, counter actions such because the initiative “Well being at each measurement” have occurred. Questions in regards to the huge give attention to chubby, well being threat, and weight reduction methods have been raised [7]. Motivation for weight reduction isn’t at all times current in individuals with chubby, and there’s proof suggesting that the super give attention to weight reduction and weight reduction methods could be complicated and even unhealthy [7]. Moreover, researchers from a number of tutorial disciplines are questioning among the central claims in regards to the existence of an weight problems epidemic and the alleged relations between chubby and weight problems and hostile well being outcomes [8].
Regardless of this, prevention and therapy concerning chubby and weight problems within the youthful age-groups have change into more and more related in analysis and public well being insurance policies [9]. There was little analysis on socio-cultural determinants of meals habits, bodily exercise and physique measurement notion [10]. Younger adults comprise a very fascinating group in relation to the subjects of weight discount and weight upkeep. They’re in a vital stage of their life-course, about to ascertain patterns of meals practices, bodily exercise and life-style habits generally [11, 12]. Moreover, younger girls are thought of susceptible concerning weight achieve, weight upkeep and life-style points [13]. Inner components, equivalent to bodily and psychological adjustments are extremely related in adolescents and younger adults. Substantial environmental adjustments, equivalent to shifting out of the parental dwelling and altering faculty or work surroundings together with social and cultural influences are prone to have an effect on their normal dwelling habits. These components are, nonetheless, not properly explored [13,14,15].
Earlier research have revealed how individuals maintain complicated and complicated theories about tips on how to keep wholesome. Well being theories and concepts about well being and illness have been influenced by prevailing ideologies and mediated by socio-structural circumstances. Moreover, the medical view has been specializing in the absence of illness, whereas lay well being believes are typically extra complicated and nuanced [16]. The difficulties with discovering efficient options for weight discount and weight upkeep remind us of the multifactorial complexity of all health-related points [5], together with the social stratifications and well being inequalities [17]. Debates in regards to the causes of and the options for the growing charges of weight problems have been happening for many years. There was a give attention to interventions in colleges and workplaces, aiming at altering people’ life-style habits, and on environmental components equivalent to restricted promoting of unhealthy meals [9]. In lots of international locations, governments have launched public insurance policies and methods concerning chubby and life-style points. One instance is “The Wholesome Individuals 2010 aim” from the US aiming at decreasing the proportion of individuals with extra weight to that present in 1970 [9]. As such methods proved to be unrealistic, initiatives aiming at prevention and collaboration with the meals business have turned up. One outstanding instance concerning prevention is the US White Home Job Power on Childhood Weight problems [3]. There are nonetheless many simplistic dichotomies within the area, equivalent to therapy versus prevention and a predominance of top-down reasonably than bottom-up drivers of change. High-down drivers are sometimes nationwide or regional initiatives for spreading details about wholesome life-style decisions, whereas bottom-up drivers are initiated to create citizen engagement. In gentle of that, youth advocacy and on-line boards might show to be necessary and efficient contributors for weight problems prevention [18].
Earlier analysis has proven that when kids and adolescents try to drop pounds, the are many alternative causes for this. Some research have proven that social stress and the want to be accepted by friends are necessary causes, whereas others report that wishes for higher look or higher well being are pivotal. Mother and father and household could be necessary influencers [19]. In adults, considerations about weight and form are widespread in each individuals with regular weight and those that are chubby, and methods on weight administration are widespread [20].
Moreover, media performs a pivotal function concerning well being and life-style points. The massive circulate of data from completely different sources gives a possibility to decide on by private preferences reasonably than reliability [21]. Younger persons are susceptible to our appearance-oriented tradition and the squeeze between cultural norms, well being messages and their very own perceptions [22]. The affect from social media and social comparability could also be strongly linked to physique dissatisfaction and adverse shallowness [23, 24].
Nevertheless, the younger shouldn’t be thought to be a homogenous group, and fluctuating subgroups are most likely quite a few [21]. Therefore, the image of underlying circumstances concerning weight points is complicated. Discrepancies between intentions and precise behaviour should be seen within the gentle of those elements.
Thus, the rationale for this research was to broaden our information inside this complexity. We did this by mixing particular person and environmental views within the presentation and dialogue of the outcomes from interviews with younger girls on the entrance to their grownup life.
The purpose of the current research was to discover how motivational and environmental components assist and impede weight discount and weight steadiness amongst younger grownup girls. Our major analysis query was: What are crucial motivational and environmental components that assist or impede life-style adjustments and weight reductions or weight upkeep amongst younger girls? We focus on our findings in relation to related public well being views on weight points within the younger inhabitants.
The research was carried out utilizing a qualitative analysis design and a phenomenological, hermeneutic strategy. To get entry to peoples’ experiences and illuminate their life-world, this methodological strategy is appropriate [25, 26]. The primary creator carried out semi- structured life-world interviews as described by Kvale & Brinkmann [27]. In such analysis interviews, the interviewer defines the state of affairs by introducing the interview subjects and critically follows up the individuals’ solutions to the questions. The aim of the interview is to acquire descriptions of the individuals’ life-world with a view to interpret the which means of the described phenomena [27]. Initially, we requested the individuals about their opinion in regards to the consideration and give attention to chubby and life-style points within the media, at college, at dwelling and in society generally. With the usage of an interview information, we secured that the next subjects had been lined: meals and diet, bodily exercise, sleeping habits, stress in on a regular basis life, media influences, and life-style as an idea (Extra file 1).
The subjects had been chosen after thorough issues of each well-known and extra just lately rising related components for life-style habits and decisions.
The included girls represented two completely different weight teams. One group was reasonably chubby or barely overweight, with a Physique Mass Index (BMI) vary from 27.0 to 32.9 kg/m2 and the opposite group was throughout the regular weight vary with a BMI vary from 18.5 to 24.9 kg/m2 [28]. The rationale for inviting two completely different teams concerning BMI-category was that we wished to discover variations in perceptions with a view to achieve a broad image. Striving for weight administration isn’t completely skilled by individuals who’re chubby. We didn’t embrace individuals near or with extreme underweight or extreme weight problems, as these individuals had been extra prone to be below medical therapy. No individuals had been youthful than 18 years, and individuals older than 21 years had been excluded. Solely younger girls had been included since weight considerations have been strongly linked to girls [13, 23]. Nevertheless, this image appears to be altering in keeping with latest analysis as physique measurement considerations have proven to be growing in male adolescents and younger males [22, 29]. Thus, the explanation for recruiting girls solely was based mostly on an intention to focus the research.
The included individuals had been recruited from the second wave of a school-based inhabitants survey, Match Futures 2 – a part of the Tromsø research, carried out in 2012/2013. To that survey, a complete of 1130 college students had been invited, and 870 participated, giving an attendance charge of 77%. All of the examinations, together with weight, top and assortment of self-reported information, had been carried out in a single go to on the Scientific Analysis Unit on the College Hospital of North Norway. A complete digital questionnaire overlaying a number of subjects was developed for the research and carried out on out there laptops. The questionnaire included background information about household, faculty and dwelling circumstances, in addition to questions on life-style habits and self-perceived well being. The typical BMI was 22.9 kg/m2 in girls and 23.4 kg/m2 in males [30]. The proportion of individuals with chubby and weight problems in keeping with the BMI classification teams as outlined by The World Well being Group (WHO) [28], was 20.3% in girls and 28.3% in males [30].
For the current qualitative research, the recruitment process was carried out by employees from the Match Futures research administration. Letters with invitation to take part had been despatched to eligible individuals. Those that wished to attend answered the invitation by mail, e-mail or telephone. The response charge was disappointingly low, solely 10% within the chubby group and 15% within the regular weight group. Causes for this might be tiredness after attending surveys, or sensible obstacles after ending faculty and shifting away. An alternative choice is that we had underestimated the sensitivity of the topic in query.
The primary creator carried out verbatim transcriptions of the interviews. By way of thematic evaluation, we recognized and reported patterns throughout the information, as described by Lindseth & Norberg [31] and Braun & Clarke [32]. Thematic evaluation is a technique for figuring out, analysing and reporting patterns or themes within the information. Extra particularly, it organizes and describes the data-set whereas emphasizing context and integrating each manifest and latent contents in a non-linear evaluation course of [32, 33]. The sensitivity for context in our research made this technique appropriate.
Moreover, although we had individuals from two completely different weight teams, comparisons between them weren’t emphasised within the interview nor within the evaluation, making thematic evaluation related [31, 32]. Opposite to a content material evaluation, a single remark was thought of as necessary as people who had been repeated [34].
The primary creator searched the texts for which means models, as sentences or paragraphs containing info vital for the analysis matter [31]. After discussions with the co-authors, the primary creator subsequently urged and developed themes by condensation of the which means models. We recognized themes by an interpretive course of, scrutinizing all of the which means models from one interview and mixing them with models and themes from the opposite interviews [35]. We selected themes on how they captured important components in relation to the analysis query [31, 33]. The evaluation was carried out as a reflexive course of, with re-reading and coding for a lot of potential themes [32, 34]. All through the research, from planning to publication, we saved an audit path documenting all necessary notes and amendments made on the best way.
The interviews had been carried out on the Scientific Analysis Unit on the College Hospital of North Norway, shortly after the completion of the Match Futures 2 survey. The interviews had been audiotape recorded and the period of every interview was between 43 and 81 min, with a imply period of 56 min. All of the individuals had been dwelling within the coastal township of Tromsø, a college metropolis within the Northern a part of Norway with an total ethnical, spiritual and cultural homogenous inhabitants. The variety of inhabitants is roughly 72.000, with the bulk dwelling within the city centre. The individuals’ traits are proven in Desk 1.
The leads to the current research are primarily based mostly on experiences of the younger girls within the chubby group. The information from the conventional weight individuals are used primarily as complementary information. The comparative aspect of the recruitment technique was utilized in a earlier paper [36]. For the current research, comparability was much less necessary. Individuals with regular weight supplied helpful info as weight considerations appears to be widespread in all weight teams in younger adults. As well as, prevention of unhealthy weight achieve is extremely necessary within the youthful age teams.
As already talked about, mixing particular person and environmental components in our seek for supporting and obstructing components is a core aspect in our research as proven in Desk 2. Each dichotomies are necessary whereas we construction, current and focus on our empirical information.
All of the individuals within the chubby group explicitly expressed honest needs and aspirations for weight discount and constructive life-style adjustments through the interviews. Nevertheless, some individuals described this as extra necessary than others. Ambivalence and contradictions in the best way these younger girls mirrored on their physique weight and points linked to life-style, well being and well-being, had been seen within the information:
I’ve at all times wished to change into slim, and I nonetheless do.
(Participant 1, chubby group)
I wouldn’t thoughts being thinner however I don’t have any issues with my look…I train a few occasions every week and I eat usually.
(Participant 2, chubby group)
Within the latter quote, the participant made it clear that wholesome life-style habits had been extra necessary for her than the burden challenge. A number of individuals talked about constructive expectations of and experiences from conducting life-style adjustments impartial of simply losing a few pounds:
I’ve higher attitudes concerning meals now than I used to have….
and I’m typically happier…I eat much less and I eat more healthy meals.
(Participant 1, chubby group)
I actually do (want to change into extra lively), not a lot for enhancing my look however as a result of I do need to dwell more healthy.
(Participant 3, chubby group)
Moreover, some individuals clearly expressed adverse emotions when speaking about how they skilled their chubby:
I think about my chubby each morning after I dress, questioning what to put on.
(Participant 4, chubby group)
It is a incontrovertible fact that people who find themselves chubby have decrease self-confidence.
(Participant 3, chubby group)
Most individuals described bodily exercise as genuinely joyful pursuits, however extremely relying on social settings. They’d good childhood reminiscences from experiences like taking part in workforce sports activities or hikes with household and buddies.
One participant within the regular weight group described how bodily inactivity and subsequently weight achieve briefly made her really feel uncomfortable and even depressed. Finally, she managed to extend her degree of exercise once more and described it like this:
After I began exercising once more, it helped insanely.
(Participant 11, regular weight group)
She described how resuming her excessive degree of exercise felt like a giant aid, making her really feel loads higher in all regards.
One participant from the chubby group described how she had truly managed to alter her habits:
I used to have dangerous habits, I had perhaps one meal every day and that might be actually massive. I’ve modified my consuming habits, now I’ve three or 4 meals every day …and I’ve stopped consuming sweet and ingesting candy drinks every single day…and I’m actually pleased with myself…I wouldn’t have the cravings for sweets anymore.
(Participant 2, chubby group)
This participant clearly skilled elevated confidence and satisfaction concerning her personal capacity to enhance her life-style habits.
Relating to wholesome diet and good consuming habits, girls in each weight teams felt that they wanted extra info and extra information. Most of them couldn’t bear in mind studying a lot about this at school. There gave the impression to be appreciable confusion about what sort of meals is definitely wholesome, as these individuals within the chubby group said:
I believe it’s tough to know what’s wholesome…I learn and listen to loads about it, however what is definitely wholesome? There isn’t a level in telling us to “eat wholesome!” once we don’t know what sort of meals that’s wholesome.
(Participant 6, chubby group)
Regardless of outspoken lack of awareness, one participant stated that she was extremely conscious of her personal unhealthy consuming habits:
It’s a bit humorous…I do have dangerous consuming habits…not that I eat junk meals, however I solely have one actual meal through the day…I’m not hungry within the morning, I don’t eat whereas I’m at college, and after I get dwelling for dinner I eat loads and I don’t get hungry once more after that.
(Participant 3, chubby group)
It was fairly widespread for some individuals to skip peculiar meals, and a few weren’t keen to sacrifice the deal with of consuming sweets and snacks:
It will get so boring (when requested about what’s stopping her from consuming more healthy) I like consuming sweets! It’s so good to take a seat down with the ladies and have sweets and sweet.
(Participant 6, chubby group)
A necessity for extra dependable details about good diet, higher consuming habits and wholesome meals had been current in each weight teams. A number of individuals talked about Web blogs as an necessary supply of details about meals and health. Nevertheless, they questioned the reliability of this info:
There’s loads of nonsense (when discussing blogs) …and even bullshit, if I’ll say so.
(Participant 6, chubby group)
This participant described how social media made her really feel like being in two completely different worlds; the media world and “the true one”.
Individuals within the regular weight group additionally expressed their scepticism concerning blogs:
Some blogs are about train and might be helpful…. however individuals ought to concentrate on the truth that among the bloggers actually don’t have a clue.
(Participant 09, regular weight group)
Some bloggers can affect individuals to eat more healthy…however I do assume that folks ought to make their very own judgements about what’s greatest for themselves.
(Participant 11, regular weight group)
Nevertheless, some highlighted the constructive results of blogs concerning life-style:
The bloggers are actual individuals, they usually all have their niches and themes, on train or meals…and a few present good recipes and a give attention to wholesome consuming.
(Participant 12, regular weight group)
The information indicated insecurity and an apparent ambivalence among the many individuals concerning messages from the media, specifically Web blogs concerning.
wholesome meals decisions. The shortage of dependable sources of data was apparent.
Relating to obstacles for bodily exercise, one participant within the chubby group described experiences from former classes of Private Train (PE) at school and the state of affairs within the dressing room:
I nearly felt embarrassed…while you’re standing within the dressing room and you understand that you’ve gained weight and also you’re not snug….it’s not cool to get undressed, and even worse, to go within the bathe.
(Participant 4, chubby group)
On this method, the participant described her emotions about revealing her physique form in entrance of her classmates. She felt uncomfortable and nearly humiliated, and described this as an impediment for taking part in bodily exercise.
One other participant within the chubby group described how a member of the family’s actions beforehand had destroyed her motivation for weight-loss:
My weight was measured each week (by a member of the family) and I grew very pissed off…I ended up rebelling after I reached secondary faculty.
(Participant 5, chubby group)
Regardless of her rebel and blended emotions, she made it clear that weight discount was one thing she actually desired. It’s considerably exhausting to interpret if these adverse emotions about being chubby is an incentive for life-style adjustments or not. She was clearly motivated, however there have been additionally indicators of frustration and opposition revealing a extra adverse perspective for making the mandatory effort.
Practically all individuals in each weight-groups described their mother and father as supportive motivators concerning chubby and life-style issues. Those that had been nonetheless dwelling with their mother and father (Desk 1) described this pretty much as good for attaining or sustaining a wholesome life-style. When requested about crucial influencers for a wholesome life-style, one of many individuals within the chubby group replied:
I’d say my mother and father…they affect me in a constructive method, issues might have been loads worse with out their training and information on life-style points.
(Participant 3, chubby group)
A number of individuals talked about household guidelines and father or mother supervision as necessary regarding sleeping habits by adolescence, as these expressions exhibit:
I used to be by no means allowed to sleep all morning, so I’ve at all times saved my hours.
(Participant 11, regular weight group)
My mother and father closed down the web entry within the evenings.
(Participant 12, regular weight group)
The individuals talked about many causes for being bodily lively. Those that had been exercising regularly highlighted the pleasure and the social elements of those actions, as this participant from the chubby group:
I liked being a part of a workforce (about being lively as a soccer participant), we had a lot enjoyable. I made a giant effort in PE at college as a result of this was the place I might simply obtain good outcomes/marks.
(Participant 6, chubby group)
One participant from the conventional weight-group emphasised the enjoyment and the assist of friends:
It’s a give attention to the perfect physique…we train as a result of it’s enjoyable, not as a result of we’ve to…it’s a good circle, we maintain one another going …earlier than it was necessary to be lean, now it’s necessary to be robust…there are numerous issues you’re speculated to be…simply not chubby.
(Participant 10, regular weight group)
This participant made a degree of being lean or match as a distinction to being chubby. Health and the pursuit of wanting robust was a recurrent matter, particularly within the regular weight group.
Some individuals additionally stated it was simpler to enhance and preserve construction in on a regular basis life after they had been employed in a job in comparison with being a pupil. As expressed by this participant within the chubby group:
For me, weight discount grew to become simpler with the on a regular basis routines that comes with a daily job.
(Participant 4, chubby group)
This view was confirmed by a participant within the regular weight group:
I discovered it simpler to take care of construction and regularity after I completed faculty and began to work full time. Work is extra necessary than faculty. I simply can’t oversleep.
(Participant 8, regular weight group)
These individuals felt an elevated sense of accountability and reliability after they moved from higher secondary faculty to the function of staff (Desk 1). Being bodily lively on a excessive degree was additionally linked to raised sleeping patterns, as described by this regular weight participant:
I am going to mattress early every evening, round 9 o’clock. I would like loads of sleep.
It’s type of boring however I simply should…I don’t carry out properly if I’m sleep disadvantaged.
(Participant 7, regular weight group)
Whereas mother and father’ affect was highlighted pretty much as good for wholesome life-style habits, shifting out appeared to contain challenges (Desk 1). A number of the extra sensible and environmental elements of the transition into maturity had been expressed as main obstacles in connection to life-style decisions. The individuals regularly talked about shifting away from the parental dwelling, new faculty or work settings, and normal stress as challenges concerning meals and train habits.
The individuals relied on their mother and father’ efforts to organize and serve them wholesome meals, and stated it might be difficult to dwell as much as these requirements after they moved out:
A few of my buddies who’re dwelling on their very own are telling me that they don’t have scorching meals every single day…that sounds terrible, sandwiches for dinner! …however I’m positive I’d do the identical of their state of affairs.
(Participant 10, regular weight)
This participant within the regular weight group was nearly crammed with dread when eager about the day she needed to put together her personal meals.
One participant within the chubby group merely stated:
After I lived with my mom we had first rate meals, like fish and hen, while you share kitchen with 5 different individuals it’s simpler to only seize a frozen pizza.
(Participant 6, chubby group)
A number of the individuals had the expertise of shifting away from their parental dwelling when beginning higher secondary faculty on the age of 16, and one participant within the chubby group described the adjustments concerned like this:
I was lean, I did loads of train, had a superb rhythm in life…then faculty began and I fell ailing with an an infection, lacked the vitality for train…had a protracted method to journey to high school…didn’t prepare dinner for myself.
(Participant 4, chubby group)
Moreover, she described how this initiated an extended interval of weight achieve, temper adjustments and even melancholy all through higher secondary faculty.
Individuals in each teams described sensible obstacles that occurred after shifting away from dwelling, significantly in relation to wholesome meals decisions, excessive prices of wholesome meals, lack of time to organize wholesome meals and shared kitchen amenities. Some girls said that they might not have been in a position to afford to attend gyms or different sport amenities if that they had not been economically supported by their mother and father, particularly after shifting out.
As talked about earlier than, a lot of the individuals had good reminiscences of being bodily lively durng childhood.
lively throughout childhood. Nevertheless, some had fairly completely different tales to inform when it got here to PE classes in higher secondary faculty, particularly within the chubby group:
They (the academics) consider the end result and never the trouble…and I discovered that extraordinarily demotivating, it was only a hassle…PE classes ought to be enjoyable!
(Participant 2, chubby group)
The give attention to outcomes and attaining good marks was an necessary facet, they usually described this as problematic and even unfair and discriminating. The notion of a singular give attention to outcomes was supported by among the individuals within the regular weight group:
There was a singular give attention to achievements, I simply discovered it demotivating!
(Participant 12, regular weight group).
Nevertheless, we discovered huge variations in experiences from PE classes, with descriptions starting from “nice enjoyable” to “extraordinarily demotivating”. Enthusiasm in the direction of bodily exercise was not restricted to the conventional weight group. Importantly, all of the individuals in each teams described bodily exercise as an necessary supply for well-being. The individuals had varied causes for being bodily lively, and located motivation from completely different sources.
Descriptions of the gymnasium as a social assembly level or the enjoyment of being a part of a sports activities workforce had been recurrent findings in each weight teams. The social facet of various sorts of bodily exercise was clearly extremely valued. The venues for or alternatives to those experiences had been, nonetheless, word simply discovered by all individuals.
All individuals described ending higher secondary faculty as a significant transition in life. One participant within the regular weight group described it as a tough step with loads of expectations and surprises:
After I began at College…I discovered myself in an unknown surroundings,I met new individuals on a regular basis…I felt exhausted…it was terrible! I didn’t train for 3 months, I actually felt the stress and I gained weight….I grew to become actually depressed.
(Participant 11, regular weight group)
By the point of the interview, she felt that she had regained steadiness, however she described the expertise as a little bit of a shock. The seriousness and the stress of attaining good outcomes at college, getting a superb training and consequently enter new environments had been nearly an excessive amount of, as expressed by one other participant in the identical group:
You’re feeling the stress in loads of methods…to attain good outcomes at college with out being thought to be a nerd…to seek out buddies…to seek out your self.
(Participant 12, regular weight group)
As these expressions reveal, stress by way of imbalance between expectations and experiences was an issue, particularly in relation to high school/work conditions and the overall construction of life. Notably, all of the individuals within the chubby group talked about sleeping issues, typically described as linked to a scarcity of construction of their on a regular basis life. One participant within the chubby group described utilizing the pc as a motive for staying up late:
It feels so snug to only sit there along with your laptop computer as an alternative of going to sleep…generally I’ve about 3-4 hours of sleep throughout evening and I’ve to take a nap after faculty…it turns into a viscous circle.
(Participant 5, chubby group)
One other participant in the identical group described sleeping issues in reference to a short lived dropout from faculty:
I slept through the day and stayed up a lot of the evening…and I needed to wrestle to alter that sample…ultimately I needed to ask for sleeping treatment.
(Participant 2, chubby group)
Environmental obstacles equivalent to new dwelling circumstances, stress in connection to new faculty settings, want for extra dependable info and higher expertise concerning wholesome meals, in addition to accessible and inexpensive methods of being bodily lively, had been outstanding in our outcomes. We’ll now focus on our findings within the gentle of the tensions between motivational components and these obstacles.
The purpose of the research was to discover the presence and affect of motivation and exterior components and their affect on weight administration in younger girls. The outcomes confirmed an apparent presence of motivation among the many individuals alongside skilled obstacles of their surroundings. Structuring the outcomes across the particular person/environmental and the supportive/obstructive dichotomies revealed fascinating patterns in our information. First, two completely different themes emerged concerning particular person issues and intrinsic motivation. One was the want to be thinner and the difficulties of attaining this among the many individuals within the chubby group. The opposite was how life-style adjustments involving more healthy meals and consuming habits, and being extra bodily lively, had been related to elevated well-being in each weight teams. This was not solely depending on needs for weight discount or weight steadiness, but additionally linked to normal well-being and improved self-confidence (Desk 2, sq. 1). Nevertheless, the outspoken lack of dependable sources of details about wholesome diet (Desk 2, sq. 2) was described as an necessary impediment on the person degree.
Help from mother and father was clearly current, and the individuals appeared grateful for this (Desk 2, sq. 3). They described their mother and father’ affect as typically necessary for sustaining a wholesome life-style, particularly by higher diet and consuming habits. Gortmaker et al. [9], highlights the accountability and alternatives that oldsters and caregivers have in selling lifelong wholesome behaviours amongst kids and adolescents. A number of research have proven that wholesome consuming like fruit and vegetable consumption amongst schoolchildren and college students are extremely depending on socio-economic components, parental affect and residential availability [37,38,39]. Whereas our findings supported the impression of fogeys’ function as necessary, we additionally discovered substantial vulnerability, despite supportive households (Desk 2, sq. 4). The individuals described it as a problem to dwell as much as their mother and father’ requirements of diet and getting ready of meals. As well as, a number of individuals said that top prices of wholesome meals and sport actions had been obstacles for a wholesome life-style as a result of dwelling on their very own as college students or working in low-income jobs compelled them to maintain their bills down. These findings are in keeping with earlier analysis, describing that the life stage of adolescence and early maturity includes a wide range of bodily, cultural, social and psychological adjustments [22]. When the younger depart dwelling, they make their very own decisions on weight-reduction plan and different life-style habits. For some, and particularly younger girls, this is a chance to insurgent in opposition to their mother and father [11]. A number of research have discovered the transition part from higher secondary faculty to college to be particularly susceptible concerning weight achieve [13].
Our findings point out that well being training could be necessary in methods concerning therapy and prevention of chubby within the younger. There are a number of doable approaches. A technique is to attempt to stress, persuade or coerce, one other method is to empower and strengthen the people’ capability of taking management of their well being [21]. For instance, diet training has been proven to be simplest when it stimulates studying, expertise and motion, reasonably than simply offering information [40]. That is in keeping with findings from social and psychological sciences. Intrinsic motivation shouldn’t be underestimated in the case of human behaviour. In our research, necessary parts linked to Self-Dedication Principle, specifically autonomy, mastery and function, as described by Ryan and Deci [41], had been simply recognised within the individuals’ descriptions of why life-style adjustments had been fascinating and the way they might be achieved. Emotions of satisfaction, pleasure, well-being, and better confidence in connection to profitable enhancements of life-style habits had been clearly seen in our information (Desk 2, Sq. 1).
Relating to bodily exercise, the information reveal some fascinating contradictions regarding motivation and obstacles, intentions and apply. The social facet of bodily exercise and having enjoyable was necessary (Desk 2, sq. 3). Alternatively, we discovered adverse experiences linked to PE at school, particularly throughout late adolescence/higher secondary faculty (Desk 2, sq. 2 and 4). These experiences had been linked to the best way the academics evaluated performances and efforts, and had been described as demotivating by individuals from each weight teams. Moreover, some experiences had been linked to sensitivity concerning physique measurement and form, which in flip was described as a demotivating issue by individuals from the chubby group.
Some individuals talked about healthiness and health as necessary subjects. The give attention to health and look within the media, and particularly the social media, has been linked to unintended penalties, equivalent to decrease shallowness, adverse temper and physique dissatisfaction in younger girls [23, 24]. Nevertheless, these individuals expressed that train and health had been a part of their id. The massive selection in preferences, attitudes and levels of motivation concerning bodily exercise on this gender and age group might show to be a problem for public well being insurance policies. Though not very seen in our information, we cannot rule out that some individuals with chubby don’t want to drop pounds. Nevertheless, it’s noteworthy that by individuals in each weight teams, merely feeling properly was offered as a significant motive for exercising or being bodily lively (Desk 1, sq. 1).
The individuals regularly talked about stress, largely in reference to faculty and training, as a adverse issue concerning the power to enhance life-style (Desk 2, sq. 4). Moreover, sleeping issues had been reported by a number of individuals, particularly within the chubby group (Desk 2, sq. 4). Poor sleep, by way of each quick and lengthy sleep period, is related to weight achieve and weight problems [42]. In keeping with The Norwegian Public Well being Institute [43], the common sleep period in Norwegian youngsters is 2 hours decrease than beneficial for this age group. In keeping with our information, dangerous sleeping habits gave the impression to be linked to a normal lack of routines in on a regular basis life. Moreover, our findings indicated that ending faculty and beginning to work appeared to assist. As said by among the individuals, work is thought to be extra necessary than faculty in the case of being punctual and performing your duties. There was an apparent and noteworthy distinction between adverse stress in connection to high school and constructive experiences of accountability and regularity when having a job.
A faculty based mostly inhabitants research fashioned the idea for the pattern, securing that age, dwelling space and faculty development had been comparable for all individuals. The response charge was, nonetheless, disappointingly low. The small pattern might represent a limitation. Nevertheless, purposive sampling and producing experiential information isn’t relying solely on the variety of individuals. We regarded the information as wealthy and vivid sufficient to explain the elements of life-world that was in our scope.
We didn’t embrace direct questions on physique picture considerations within the interview information, and it is a potential limitation concerning the rising themes from the information. Consuming problems are moreover not commented within the paper, and this represent a doable limitation of the research. It’s well-known that physique weight, physique picture and consuming problems are intently linked, and ought to be thought of collectively reasonably than individually when finding out weight considerations [14, 44, 45].
The exclusion of male individuals is one other limitation. Physique measurement considerations with following penalties concerning weight problems prevention and well being promotion should not completely skilled by girls. Nevertheless, this was a call taken early through the planning of the research with a view to have a centered paper. The urged implications of the research ought to be seen as tentative given the small pattern and doable limitations concerning themes within the interview information.
There’s at all times a query of transferability concerning geographical areas and contingencies equivalent to sociocultural elements. Related references and cultural values along with the event concerning media and trendy communication methods ought to make the findings comparable throughout the Western world.
To summarize, we discovered an apparent pressure between particular person, motivational components and environmental components when discussing weight administration and life-style decisions with younger girls. Our findings point out that backside up methods equivalent to well being training aiming at strengthening people’ capability of taking management of their life-style and well being might show to be helpful. Making wholesome meals extra accessible and inexpensive in addition to providing low-cost options for organized sports activities ought to be thought of in public well being methods within the goal group.
The findings of constructive experiences of improved life-style habits when being staff and never college students ought to be pursued in future analysis.
Extra analysis in larger samples, and in each genders, is required to pursue these findings and their relevance for public well being methods and needed structural adjustments.
Physique mass index
Private train
College of Tromsø
World Well being Group
NCD Threat Issue Collaboration (NCD-RisC). Developments in grownup body-mass index in 200 international locations from 1975 to 2015: a pooled evaluation of 1698 population-based measurements research with 19.2 million individuals. Lancet. 2016;387:1377–96.
Article Google Scholar
LeBesco Ok. Neoliberalism, public well being, and the ethical perils of fatness. Essential Public Well being. 2011;21:153–64.
Article Google Scholar
Roberto CA, Swinburn B, Hawkes C, Huang TT-Ok, Costa SA, Ashe M, et al. Patchy progress on weight problems prevention: rising examples, entrenched obstacles, and new pondering. Lancet. 2015;385:2400–9.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Ferraro ZM, Patterson S, Chaput JP. Unhealthy weight management practices: culprits and scientific suggestions. Clin Med Insights Endocrinol Diabetes. 2015;8:7–11.
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Brown BJ, Baker S. Accountable residents. People, Well being and coverage below Neoliberalism. London: Anthem Press; 2013.
Google Scholar
Rose G. Sick people and sick populations. Int J Epidemiol. 1985;14:32–8.
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Bacon L. Well being at each measurement. The shocking reality about your weight. Dallas: Benbella Books, Inc; 2008.
Google Scholar
Campos P, Saguy A, Ernsberger P, Oliver E, Gaesser G. The epidemiology of chubby and weight problems: public well being disaster or ethical panic? Int J Epidemiol. 2006;35(1):55–60.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Gortmaker SL, Swinburn BA, Levy D, Carter R, Mabry PL, Finegood DT, et al. Altering the way forward for weight problems: science, coverage, and motion. Lancet. 2011;378:838–47.
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Swinburn BA, Sacks G, Corridor KD, McPherson Ok, Finegood DT, Moodie ML, et al. The worldwide weight problems pandemic: formed by world drivers and native environments. Lancet. 2011;378:804–14.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Lupton D. Meals, the physique and the self. London: SAGE Publications; 1996.
Google Scholar
Faw MH. Younger adults’ methods for managing social assist throughout weight-loss makes an attempt. Qual Well being Res. 2014;24:267–78.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Wane S, van Uffelen JG, Brown W. Determinants of weight achieve in younger girls: a evaluate of the literature. J Girls’s Well being (Larchmt). 2010;19:1327–40.
Article Google Scholar
Neumark-Sztainer D, Paxton SJ, Hannan PJ, Haines J, Story M. Does physique Satisfation matter? 5-year longitudinal associations between physique satisfaction and Well being Behaviours in adolescent females and males. J Adolesc Well being. 2006;39:244–51.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Friscoe ML, Houle JN, Lippert AM. Weight change and melancholy amongst US younger girls through the transition to maturity. Am J Epidemiol. 2013;178:22–30.
Article Google Scholar
Nettleton S. The sociology of Well being and sickness. third ed. Cambridge: Polity Press; 2013.
Google Scholar
Lahelma E. Well being and Social Stratification. In: Cockerham WC, editor. The Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2005. p. 64-93.
Huang TT, Cawley JH, Ashe M, Costa SA, Frerichs LM, Zwicker L, et al. Mobilisation of public assist for coverage actions to stop weight problems. Lancet. 2015;385:2422–31.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Braden AL, Crow S, Boutelle Ok. Baby self-reported motivations for weight reduction: affect of non-public vs. social/familial motives on family-based behavioural weight reduction therapy outcomes. Eat Weight Disord. 2015;20:205–13.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Nissen NK, Holm L. Literature evaluate: perceptions and administration of physique measurement amongst regular weight and reasonably chubby individuals. Obes Rev. 2015;16:150–60.
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Inexperienced J, Tones Ok. Well being promotion. Planning and methods. London: SAGE; 2010.
Google Scholar
Voelker DK, Reel JJ, Greenleaf C. Weight standing and physique picture perceptions in adolescents: present views. Adolesc Well being Med Ther. 2015;6:149–58.
PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Tiggeman M, Zaccardo M. ”Train to be match, not skinny”: the impact of fitspiration imagery on girls’s physique picture. Physique Picture. 2015;15:61-7.
Fardouly J, Deidrichs PC, Vartanian LR, Halliwell E. Social comparisons on the social media: the affect of Fb on younger girls’s physique picture considerations and temper. Physique Picture. 2015;13:38–45.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Dahlberg Ok, Drew N, Nyström M. Reflective Lifeworld analysis. Studentlitteratur: Lund; 2008.
Google Scholar
Polit DF, Beck CT. Nursing analysis. Producing and assessing proof for nursing apply. eighth ed. Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer. Lippincote Williams & Wilkins; 2008.
Google Scholar
Kvale S, Brinkmann S. Interviews. Studying the craft of qualitative analysis interviewing. London: SAGE; 2009.
Google Scholar
WHO World Well being Group. World database on Physique Mass Index. www.assessmentpsychology.com/icbmi.htm. Accessed 2 Might 2017.
Mitchison D, Mond J. Epidemiology of consuming problems, consuming disordered behaviour, and physique picture disturbance in males: a story evaluate. J Eat Disord. 2015;3:20.
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Sand AS, Furberg AS, Lian OS, Nielsen CS, Pettersen G, Winther A, et al. A cross-sectional research on the variations between measured, perceived and desired physique measurement and the relation to self-perceived well being in younger adults. The Tromsø research: match Futures. Scand J Publ Well being. 2017;1:1403494817690941. doi:10.1177/1403494817690941. [Epub ahead of print]
Google Scholar
Lindseth A, Norberg A. A phenomenological hermeneutical technique for researching lived expertise. Scand J Caring Sci. 2004;18:145–53.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Braun V, Clarke V. Utilizing thematic evaluation in psychology. Qualitative Res Psychol. 2008;3:77–101.
Article Google Scholar
Vaismoradi M, Turunen H, Bondas T. Content material evaluation and thematic evaluation: implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive research. Nurs Well being Sci. 2013;15:398–405.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Fereday J, Muir-Cochrane E. Demonstrating rigor utilizing thematic evaluation: a hybrid strategy of inductive and deductive coding and theme growth. Int J Qualitative Meth. 2006;5:80–92.
Google Scholar
Morse JM. Analytic methods and pattern measurement. Qual Well being Res. 2015;25:1317–8.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Sand AS, Emaus N, Lian OS. Obese and weight problems in younger grownup girls: a matter of well being or look? The Tromsø research: match Futures. Int J Qual Stud Well being Properly-being. 2015;10:29026.
Article Google Scholar
Nilsen SM, Krokstad S, Holmen TL, Westin S. Adolescents’ health-related dietary patterns by parental socio-economic place, the Nord-Trøndelag Well being research (HUNT). Eur J Pub Well being. 2010;20:299–305.
Article Google Scholar
Wind M, te Welde SJ, Brug J, Sandvik C, Klepp KI. Weight loss program and direct interplay between environmental components and fruit consumption, mediation by psychosocial components: the professional kids research. Public Well being Nutr. 2010;13:1736–45.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Sandvik C, Gjestad R, Samdal O, Brug J, Klepp KI. Does socio-economic standing reasonable the associations between psychosocial predictors and fruit consumption in schoolchildren? The professional kids research. Well being Educ Res. 2010;25:121–34.
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Hawkes C, Smith TG, Jewell J, Wardle J, Hammond RA, Friel S, et al. Good meals insurance policies for weight problems prevention. Lancet. 2015;385:2410–21.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Ryan RM, Deci EL. Self-determination concept and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social growth, and well-being. Am Psychol. 2000;55:68–78.
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Chaput JP, Després JP, Bouchard C, Tremblay A. The affiliation between quick sleep period and weight achieve relies on disinhibited consuming behaviour in adults. Sleep. 2011;34:1291–7.
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Norwegian Institute of Public Well being. Sleep issues in Norway. Public Well being Report. 2014. https://www.fhi.no/en/mp/sleep-and-sleep-disorders/. Accessed 2 Might 2017.
Mitchison D, Hay P, Griffiths S, Murray SB, Bentley C, Gratwick-Sarll Ok, Harrison C, Mond J. Disentangling physique picture: the relative associations of overvaluation, dissatisfaction, and preoccupation with psychological misery and consuming dysfunction behaviors in female and male adolescents. Int J Eat Disord. 2017;50(2):118–26.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Fredrickson J, Kremer P, Swinburn B, de Silva A, McCabe M. Weight notion in chubby adolescents: associations with physique change intentions, weight-reduction plan and bodily exercise. J Well being Psychol. 2015;20(6):774–84.
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Download references
The authors wish to thank the research individuals for sharing their ideas and making the research doable. We’re grateful to the Match Futures administration and the Scientific Analysis Division on the College Hospital of North Norway for serving to with the sampling and recruitment procedures.
The research was supported by a grant from the Northern Norway Regional Well being Authority. The funding physique didn’t have any function within the design of the research, the writing of the manuscript nor within the assortment, evaluation and interpretation of the information.
The uncooked information is confidential and consists of audiotape information and transcripts. Information could also be shared with researchers acquiring permissions from the Tromsø Research Administration (http://www.tromsostudy.com) and The Regional Committee for Medical and Well being Analysis Ethics; REC North.
ASS conceptualised and designed the research, collected and analysed the information, and contributed to the writing of the manuscript. NE and OSL contributed to the research design, to the information evaluation and to the writing of the manuscript. All authors learn and authorized the ultimate manuscript.
The authors declared no potential conflicts of curiosity with respect to the analysis, authorship, and/or publication of this text.
Not relevant.
Moral approval to conduct the research was obtained from The Regional Committee for Medical and Well being Analysis Ethics; REC North (reference quantity 2012/1621). Details about the research was given and written consent to take part was obtained from the individuals earlier than the interviews had been carried out. The individuals acquired a present voucher (worth 200 NOK equal to 25 EUR) as compensation for journey bills. The consent type said that taking part was voluntary, and declining to take part wouldn’t have any penalties for the person.
Springer Nature stays impartial with regard to jurisdictional claims in revealed maps and institutional affiliations.
Division of Scientific Analysis, College Hospital of North Norway, 9038, Tromsø, Norway
Anne-Sofie Sand & Olaug S. Lian
Division of Well being and Care Sciences, College of Well being Sciences, UiT The Arctic College of Norway, 9037, Tromsø, Norway
Nina Emaus
Division of Group Drugs, College of Well being Sciences, UiT The Arctic College of Norway, 9037, Tromsø, Norway
Olaug S. Lian
You may also seek for this creator in PubMed Google Scholar
You may also seek for this creator in PubMed Google Scholar
You may also seek for this creator in PubMed Google Scholar
Correspondence to Anne-Sofie Sand.
Interview information. Matters and questions used within the interviews, translated from Norwegian. (DOCX 99 kb)
Open Entry This text is distributed below the phrases of the Artistic Commons Attribution 4.0 Worldwide License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which allows unrestricted use, distribution, and replica in any medium, supplied you give acceptable credit score to the unique creator(s) and the supply, present a hyperlink to the Artistic Commons license, and point out if adjustments had been made. The Artistic Commons Public Area Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the information made out there on this article, until in any other case said.
Reprints and permissions
Sand, AS., Emaus, N. & Lian, O.S. Motivation and obstacles for weight administration amongst younger girls – a qualitative research with a public well being focus – the Tromsø research: Match Futures . BMC Public Well being 17, 417 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-017-4321-9
Download citation
Obtained:
Accepted:
Revealed:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-017-4321-9
Anybody you share the next hyperlink with will be capable to learn this content material:
Sorry, a shareable hyperlink isn’t at present out there for this text.
Supplied by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
Commercial
ISSN: 1471-2458
Through the use of this web site, you conform to our Terms and Conditions, Your US state privacy rights, Privacy statement and Cookies coverage. Your privacy choices/Manage cookies we use within the desire centre.
© 2024 BioMed Central Ltd until in any other case said. A part of Springer Nature.
